From Publishers Weekly
This book masterfully reinterprets the founding era of South Africa,
especially the 19th century, to emphasize not the Afrikaners but the
conflict between British colonials and the indigenous Xhosa people.
Drawing on virtually forgotten government records and vivifying
little-known people, Mostert ( Supership ) has done for South Africa
what Robert Hughes did for Australia in The Fatal Shore . Mostert places
South Africa in the framework, both geographical and moral, of world
colonial expansion; Britain's Cape Colony, site of an experiment in
political liberalism, illustrates the era's tension "between high-minded
conscience and self-interest."
To reconstruct this "crucible of modern
South African society," the author conjures up multiple worlds in
passages often intricate and lyrical, though the depth of detail may
deter readers. He draws on historiography, geography, linguistics and
archeology to portray the European scramble for Africa, the cosmology of
the indigenous Bushmen and the lives of the Afrikaners and the Zulus
but eventually focuses on the British settlers and the Cape Xhosas, a
proud people with traditions of democratic debate, communal land and
welcoming of strangers. Their interactions animate a narrative rich in
drama: the British began "probably the most callous act of mass
settlement in the entire history of empire"; the Cape was the first
society to attempt to legislate an interracial state; and when the
Xhosas, decimated by the frontier wars and vulnerable to prophecy,
killed their cattle and thus many of themselves, it was "probably the
greatest self-inflicted immolation of a people in all history." Mostert
concludes that the Cape Colony, where the nonracial franchise continued
to contract until it vanished under 20th-century apartheid, "represents
one of the greatest of lost ideals within human society."
From Library Journal
This monumental work deals primarily with conflicts between the Xhosa
and white colonizers, culminating in the 1850s when the tribe invited
mass starvation by killing their cattle and destroying their food,
convinced that this would drive away the British. It also chronicles the
moral struggle within the British Empire over the treatment of nonwhite
populations. These two dramas shaped white attitudes toward Africa and
Africans that lasted well into the 20th century and still affect South
African politics. The author, a South African-born journalist now living
in Canada, spent several years researching this well-written, absorbing
narrative which, while aimed at the general public, belongs in academic
as well as public libraries. History Book Club and Quality Paperback
Book Club alternates.
- Paul H. Thomas, Hoover Inst. Lib., Stanford, Cal.
- Paul H. Thomas, Hoover Inst. Lib., Stanford, Cal.